Welcome to Middle Island Pizza, a beloved gem located at 586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY. Renowned for its inviting atmosphere and outstanding service, this restaurant serves a mouthwatering array of dishes that cater to all tastes.
Their menu features delectable options, from the hearty Chicken Parmigiana ($12.94) to the delightful Vegetable Minestrone (complimentary). Each dish showcases a blend of fresh ingredients and culinary expertise, ensuring every bite is satisfying. Don’t miss the famous Arthur Avenue Pizzette ($20.74), a crowd favorite that captures the essence of Italian comfort food.
Customers rave about the friendly service, highlighting staff members like Larry, who adds character to your dining experience. The Rainbow Cake has also received praise for being the best in town. With options perfect for family lunches or cozy dinners, Middle Island Pizza has quickly established itself as a must-visit spot.