Hello dear
Welcome To Middle Island Pizza
Middle Island Pizza, located at 586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY, is a beloved local eatery known for its delicious pizzas and warm, welcoming atmosphere. Customers rave about the restaurant's excellent service, with many praising friendly staff members like Larry, enhancing the dining experience. The menu features a variety of dishes, including savory chicken rolls and vibrant salads, while their standout rainbow cake has garnered particular acclaim. Despite minor challenges, such as occasional service disruptions, the spirit of community and devotion to quality food make Middle Island Pizza a must-visit destination for pizza lovers in Long Island.
Taste the best
Discover Our Menu
About
Middle Island Pizza
Welcome to Middle Island Pizza, a hidden gem located at 586 Middle Country Rd, Middle Island, NY. This pizza haven has made quite the mark on the local food scene, and it's not hard to understand why. Whether you're a lifelong resident or just passing through, this establishment promises a delightful culinary experience that is both satisfying and memorable.
What sets Middle Island Pizza apart from the myriad of pizzerias is their commitment to quality and flavor. Patrons rave about the amazing pizza, with highlights including a rich tomato sauce that leaves you craving more, and a crust that perfectly balances crispiness and chewiness. Customers like Bryan B have noted the deliciousness of the food, while April DiCarlo mentions the "wonderful sauce" and recommends their renowned rainbow cake. The blend of flavors in each bite showcases the expertise of the kitchen staff.
Yet, it's not just the pizza that garners admiration. The menu features a diverse array of dishes, from appetizers like the scrumptious Baked Clams to hearty main courses such as the Veal Parm and Eggplant Rollatini. The affordability of these dishes—like the Chicken Finger Platter and Garlic Bread with Cheese—ensures that every family can enjoy a feast without breaking the bank.
The service at Middle Island Pizza is just as impressive as the food. Customers consistently remark on the friendly atmosphere and the attentiveness of the staff, particularly a standout named Larry, who has become a beloved figure among regulars. His welcoming demeanor adds a personal touch that enhances the overall dining experience, making it feel like home—a sentiment echoed by loyal patrons like Mike Kravchenko and Kirstin Thomas.
However, like any establishment, there are areas that need attention. One reviewer expressed concern about the working conditions during a recent heat wave, prompting a conversation about how important it is to ensure a supportive environment for staff. Here’s hoping that Middle Island Pizza continues to strive for excellence, not only in the food they serve but in the culture they foster within their team.
In a world where dining options are plentiful, Middle Island Pizza remains a beloved go-to spot. Whether indulging in a classic slice, savoring a hearty veal dish, or simply enjoying the company of friends and family, this pizzeria has something for everyone. Stop by and taste the joy—they truly embody the spirit of community and culinary delight.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Honestly nothing to complain about here the food is delicious. The price of pizza has gone up since I was a kid 20 years ago so can’t blame them it’s everywhere but truly a great spot for pies my wife and kids love it here ”
“ The Best pizza place on long Island very Generous people great service shout out to Larry has a Good sense of humor very respectful customer 4 life , wen I die bury me wit a Slice n 3 garlic knotss ”
“ We love Middle Island pizza, we moved here in 2020 and have been coming here ever since. They have amazing pizza, wonderful sauce and the best rainbow cake I’ve ever had! Highly recommend! Oh, and the guys and girls behind the counter couldn’t be any nicer. ”
“ Always a good experience going in there. Everyone is very friendly and attentive and overall a 10/10 place. The chicken rolls are the best on LI, too. ”
“ This is my favorite neighborhood pizza place. Food is always great, service is great. Larry is my favorite guy to see, always in high spirits and he’s so kind and welcoming. While I love this place, I am upset because during my recent visit, I was quickly learned that the ac was not on in the building. This was during our heat wave and the entire place was hot, muggy and I was sweating while waiting for my order. Larry was apologizing for the circumstance but I felt sorry for him as not only was he working, but he was dealing with extremely hot ovens and looked to be overheating himself. I do not know the reason or motive behind why there was no ac in the building during 100 degree weather but I’ve heard before that the owner is not treating staff properly and I would just like to say that we need to do better. This is a great little joint and I am happy to give it my dollars as long as I see that reflected in the way the staff is being treated overall and make sure that they are working in proper conditions. ”
“ I can't say enough of the way the food is made fresh every day. The owner takes pride in serving delicious food. A must try for old school foods mixed in with new ideas. I always enjoy at 11am seeing all the fresh specialty pies come out of the oven. Keep up the good work everyone at Middle Island Pizza. ”
“ Place is always great , Anthony the owner is awesome and I’ve never had any issues here, when I wasn’t able to eat cheese they would accommodated my request to make a cheese-less pizza. I recommend their Sicilian pizza as I like the thicker crust but they have great selection of specialty and regular slices ”
“ We all know the affiliations but gotta give Credit Individually! MI Pizza is always a WIN! How can you lose with Amazing Pizza! Years of Family Owned Service with a Smile. I feel at home! ”